
For decades, the world of fitness and dieting has focused on a simple equation: "calories in versus calories out." The overwhelming recommendation for those who wanted to shed pounds was to stick to aerobic machines - treadmills, bikes or ellipticals. But a new and extensive Israeli study from Tel Aviv University, recently published in the scientific journal Frontiers in Endocrinology , proves that it's time to update the myths. The study, led by Prof. Yiftach Gafner and Yair Lahav, states that when it comes to quality and healthy weight loss, strength training (resistance) is the undisputed winner.
One of the biggest problems with weight loss is that our bodies don't distinguish between fat and essential muscle tissue. When we are in a calorie deficit (eating less than we burn), the body looks for available energy sources. Without proper stimulation, it may break down muscle tissue to survive. The main finding of the study showed that those who performed only aerobic training, or were satisfied with a diet without exercise, did indeed lose weight - but a significant portion of the loss came from muscle mass. In contrast, participants who performed strength training were able to preserve muscle and even increase it, while losing significant fat percentages.
Muscle mass plays a critical role that goes beyond aesthetic appearance:
One of the important messages that emerges from the data is that strength training is essential for all ages (the study included people aged 20 to 75). As we age, we experience a natural process of muscle wasting (sarcopenia). Losing weight without resistance training can accelerate this process, weaken posture, and increase the risk of falls and injuries. Strength training is essentially the “insurance policy” for our physical function.
To benefit from the benefits revealed by the study, it is recommended to adopt an integrated approach: